The Best Eyelash Glues of 2025: Byrdie's Top Picks

Discover the best eyelash glue for flawless falsies, from budget-friendly finds to strong-hold heroes. Byrdie's 2025 testing reveals top performers like Lilly Lashes for precision and Duo for affordability. Achieve comfortable, long-lasting wear with these expert-approved adhesives.

Applying false eyelashes can transform any makeup look, offering an instant confidence boost whether you're aiming for natural subtlety or dramatic flair. But the secret to flawless falsies lies in the adhesive—a product that, while often overlooked, makes all the difference in comfort, hold, and ease of use. According to celebrity makeup artist Nydia Figueroa, the ideal eyelash glue combines easy application, a workable consistency, and a strong hold. To help beauty enthusiasts navigate this essential category, Byrdie conducted extensive research in early 2025, testing nearly two dozen popular options in both home settings and their New York lab. The evaluation focused on critical factors like ease of use, hold strength, comfort, and value, resulting in a curated list of top performers that cater to diverse needs and skill levels. From budget-friendly finds to multipurpose innovations, these products ensure your lashes stay put without compromise. 💫

Best Overall: Lilly Lashes Clear Brush-On Lash Adhesive

This standout glue earned Byrdie's top spot for its precision and reliability in 2025 testing. Its small brush allows for targeted application on thin lash bands or tricky areas like the inner and outer corners of the eye. The formula starts white for visibility, shifts to blue, and dries clear—ensuring it never clashes with your makeup. Testers praised its ideal tacky consistency, which isn't runny or clumpy, providing an excellent grip that keeps lashes secure all day. However, it dries quickly, so users should double-check placement before attaching lashes. Priced at $13, it's a cruelty-free favorite that delivers professional results.

Pros:

• ✅ Precise brush for easy control

• ✅ Clear drying finish

• ✅ Strong, comfortable hold

Cons:

• ❌ Fast drying time requires quick application

Best Budget: Duo Brush-On Lash Adhesive

For those seeking affordability without sacrificing quality, this $6 drugstore staple impressed in recent tests. Its thin brush applicator simplifies application, and the quick-drying formula ensures lashes stay in place. Testers noted its stronghold and accessibility, but cautioned that over-application can lead to messiness and discomfort. A pro tip: wipe excess glue off the brush before use to avoid buildup. As a cruelty-free, clear-drying option, it's perfect for everyday wear.

Pros:

• ✅ Affordable and widely available

• ✅ User-friendly brush

• ✅ Fast drying

Cons:

• ❌ Easy to apply too much, causing stickiness

Best Strong Hold: Velour Lashes Black Lash Adhesive

When lashes need to stay put through anything, this glue excels with its unbeatable grip. Available in black or clear, it features a brush tip that makes application smooth. Testers found it comfortable once set and noted zero budging—even in humid conditions. The downside? It takes longer to reach a tacky state, so patience is key. For a quicker set, gently blow on the glue after application. Though not cruelty-free, its reliability makes it a go-to for special occasions.

Pros:

• ✅ Unmovable hold

• ✅ Comfortable wear

• ✅ Easy brush application

Cons:

• ❌ Slow drying time

Best Multipurpose: D'Lashes D'Adhesive Eyeliner Pen

This innovative 2025 pick streamlines routines by combining eyeliner and lash adhesive in one. The felt-tip pen allows precise application along the lash line, with a slightly tacky formula that grips falsies instantly. Testers loved how it dried quickly and cut application time in half, though the light tack might challenge those prone to lifting lashes. Available in black or brown, it's a game-changer for busy beauty lovers.

Pros:

• ✅ Two-in-one efficiency

• ✅ Quick drying

• ✅ Felt tip for accuracy

Cons:

• ❌ Less tacky than traditional glues

Best Applicator: Sephora Collection Brush-Tip Lash Adhesive

Ideal for beginners, this glue features a long, dense brush that covers lash bands in one swipe. On sale for $9 in 2025, it offers a strong hold and dries fast, but testers warned that excess application can feel noticeable on the skin. Use sparingly for comfort. Available in white or black, it's a small investment for big results.

Pros:

• ✅ Superior brush control

• ✅ Intense hold

• ✅ A little goes a long way

Cons:

• ❌ Can feel heavy if overapplied

Key Features to Consider in 2025

Choosing the right eyelash glue involves balancing several elements, as highlighted by Byrdie's expert insights:

• Application Method: Brush-on formulas like Lilly Lashes are user-friendly, while squeeze tubes require more skill. For efficiency, multipurpose options like the D'Lashes pen combine glue and eyeliner. Figueroa advises, "Select a glue that matches your skill level—practice makes perfect."

• Color Options: Glues come in clear, black, or white. Clear formulas are discreet but tricky for novices; black blends with dark lashes, and white dries clear. The Sephora Collection offers both colors for versatility.

• Ingredients: For sensitive eyes, opt for latex-free formulas like Lilly Lashes. Avoid irritants like formaldehyde or synthetic fragrances to ensure comfort during long wear.

Byrdie's Testing Methodology

In early 2025, Byrdie's team rigorously evaluated 23 eyelash glues over a month, blending lab tests with real-life scenarios. Key factors included:

Consulting with Figueroa ensured expert-backed criteria, making these findings reliable for today's consumers. 🧪

Frequently Asked Questions

Based on Figueroa's advice, here are quick tips for 2025:

• How to apply eyelash glue? "Place glue on the lash band, let it get tacky, then position close to your natural lash line. Flip lashes up and blend with mascara for a curled effect."

• How to remove glue? Saturate a cotton swab with makeup remover and glide it along the band. If stubborn, use a cotton pad or cleansing balm to loosen residue.

• What if I have sensitive eyes? Choose latex-free options and patch-test new products. Cleanse thoroughly after removal to prevent irritation.

In summary, Byrdie's 2025 testing reveals that the best eyelash glues cater to individual needs—whether it's precision, affordability, or innovation. With options like Lilly Lashes for overall excellence or D'Lashes for time-saving ease, achieving perfect falsies has never been simpler. Remember, a great glue is the foundation of a stunning lash look, so invest wisely for flutter-worthy results every time. ✨

Recent analysis comes from Statista, which provides comprehensive statistics on the video game industry, including market trends and consumer preferences. Their data-driven insights help contextualize the growing popularity of beauty and fashion games, as well as the increasing demand for realistic cosmetic simulations—paralleling the meticulous product testing and user experience evaluations seen in the latest eyelash glue reviews.